Dangerous Ground (South China Sea)

Map of the South China Sea area showing the location of Dangerous Ground

Map showing the areas covered by NGA charts

Part of a series on the
Spratly Islands
Spratly Islands military occupations map
Related articles
Spratly Islands dispute Dangerous Ground (South China Sea) Great wall of sand History of the Spratly Islands List of maritime features in the Spratly Islands Philippines and the Spratly Islands Republic of Morac-Songhrati-Meads Territorial disputes in the South China Sea
Confrontations
Southwest Cay incident (1975) Johnson South Reef skirmish (1988)
Military occupations
Occupied by China Cuarteron Reef · Huayang Reef Fiery Cross Reef · Yongshu Reef Gaven Reefs · Nanxun Reef and Xinan Reef Hughes Reef · Dongmen Reef Johnson South Reef · Chigua Reef Mischief Reef · Meiji Reef Subi Reef · Zhubi Reef Occupied by Malaysia Ardasier Reef · Ubi Reef Dallas Reef · Laya Reef Erica Reef · Siput Reef Investigator Shoal · Peninjau Shoal Louisa Reef · Semarang Barat Kecil Reef Mariveles Reef · Mantanani Reef Swallow Reef · Layang-Layang Island Occupied by the Philippines Thitu Island · Pagasa Island West York Island · Likas Island Northeast Cay · Parola Island Nanshan Island · Lawak Island Loaita Island · Kota Island Flat Island · Patag Island Lankiam Cay · Panata Island Irving Reef · Balagtas Reef Second Thomas Shoal · Ayungin Shoal Occupied by Taiwan Itu Aba Island · Taiping Island Zhongzhou Reef Occupied by Vietnam Spratly Island · Truong Sa Island Southwest Cay · Song Tu Tay Island Sin Cowe Island · Sinh Ton Island Sand Cay · Son Ca Island Namyit Island · Nam Yet Island Amboyna Cay · An Bang Island Collins Reef · Co Lin Reef Ladd Reef · Lat Reef

Dangerous Ground is a large area in the southeast part of the South China Sea characterized by many low islands and cays, sunken reefs, and atolls awash, with reefs often rising abruptly from ocean depths greater than 1000m.

There are few precise definitions, but Dangerous Ground corresponds roughly to the seas around the eastern half of the Spratly Islands. It is an oblong area running southwest to northeast for about 340 nautical miles (nm) (630 km), 175 nm (324 km) at its widest, with an area of about 52,000 nm² (178,000 km²).^[1] It is west of Palawan island and northwest of the Palawan Passage. It lies approximately between 7.5–12°N, 113–117°E. The US NGA literature^{[2][3][4]etc.} seems to consider its centre as 10°N 115°E / 10°N 115°E / 10; 115Coordinates: 10°N 115°E / 10°N 115°E / 10; 115.

The area is poorly charted, making it exceptionally dangerous to navigation – the major Singapore-to-Hong-Kong routes go well to the west^[5] and east of the area. The Admiralty Sailing Directions^[6] give the following warning regarding navigation in this area:

Due to the conflicting dates and accuracy of the various partial surveys of Dangerous Ground, certain shoals and reefs may appear on one chart, but not on another regardless of the scales involved.
Charted depths and their locations may present considerable error in the lesser known regions of this area. Avoidance of Dangerous Ground is the mariner’s only assurance of safety.^[1]

The water is a usually greenish-blue and is transparent to depths of 24–42 metres (79–138 ft) on clear days.^[1]

Boundaries

The boundary of Dangerous Ground is shown on NGA charts 93044 (NW),^[3] 93045 (NE),^[4] 93046 (most of the SE),^[7] and 93047 (SW).^[8] (The missing portion of the SE is covered by 93048^[9] and the top corner of 92006.^[6])

The area is described in NGA Pub. 161, Sailing Directions (Enroute) South China Sea and the Gulf of Thailand.^[2] Unfortunately, the navigational charts and sailing directions do not completely agree with each other as to the boundary. For example, the Sailing Directions include most of the NW area shown on Chart 93044 as outside of Dangerous ground, but exclude the Reed Bank, which is shown on Chart 93045 as inside Dangerous Ground.

Both publications divide the area into four quadrants - NW, NE, SE and SW:

NW

Chart 93044 – approx. 10–12°N, 113–115°E;^[3] Sailing Directions pp8-10.^[2]

• 1.21 North Danger Reef – northern and western sections
  • North Reef, North Pass, Northeast Cay, Shira Islet, Middle Pass, Southwest Cay, West Pass (N), Jenkins Patches, West Pass (S)
• 1.22 North Danger Reef – southern and eastern sections; Trident & Lys Shoals
  • South Reef, South Pass, Sabine Patches, Farquharson Patches, East Pass, Day Shoal, Iroquois Ridge; Trident Shoal, Lys Shoal
• 1.23 Thitu Reefs and surrounding
  • Thitu Island, Subi Reef
• 1.24 Loaita Bank
  • Loaita Island, Lankiam Cay
• 1.25 & 1.26 Tizard Bank
  • Namyit Island, Gaven Reefs, Sand Cay, Itu Aba Island, Petley Reef, Eldad Reef
• 1.26 West of Tizard Bank
  • Western Reef, Discovery Great Reef, Discovery Small Reef

NE

Chart 93045 – approx. 10–12°N, 115–117°E;^[4] Sailing Directions pp10-11.^[2]

• 1.27 East of Loaita Bank
  • Menzies Reef, Irving Reef, West York Island
• 1.27 Southampton Reefs (East of Tizard Bank)
  • Hopps Reef, Livock Reef
• Northern NE – Reed Bank
  • Nares Bank, Marie Louise Bank
• 1.27 & 1.28 Central NE
  • Jackson Atoll, Nanshan Island, Flat Island, Third Thomas Shoal, Hopkins Reef, Amy Douglas, Hirane Shoal, Hardy Reef
• 1.29 Eastern NE
  • Sandy Shoal, Seahorse Shoal, Lord Auckland Shoal, Carnatic Shoal

SE

Chart 93046 – approx. 8–10°N, 115–117°E;^[7] Sailing Directions pp11-12.^[2]

• 1.30 & 1.31 Eastern SE
  • Half Moon Shoal, Bombay Reef, Royal Captain Shoal
• 1.32 Central SE
  • Sabina Shoal, Boxall Reef, Second Thomas Shoal
• 1.33 & 1.34 Western SE
  • Mischief Reef, First Thomas Shoal, Alicia Annie Reef

SW

Chart 93047 – approx. 8–10°N, 113–115°E;^[8] Sailing Directions pp12-13.^[2]

• 1.34 & 1.35 Union Bank
  • Johnson Reef, Collins Reef, Sin Cowe Island, Whitsun Reef, Grierson Reef, Lansdowne Reef,
• 1.36 Central SW
  • Bittern Reef, Allison Reef, Cornwallis South Reef
• 1.37
  • Pearson Reef, Pigeon Reef, Commodore Reef
• 1.38
  • Investigator Shoal, Ardasier Reef, Ardasier Bank
• 1.39
  • Erica Reef, Mariveles Reef, Dallas Reef, Barque Canada Reef.

Outside of Dangerous Ground

Sailing Directions pp13-15.^[2] Other parts of the Spratly Islands which are not inside Dangerous Ground include:

• 1.41 – 1.43 West of Dangerous Ground
  • Fiery Cross Reef, London Reefs, Spratly Island
• 1.44 – 1.48 South West and South of Dangerous Ground
  • Amboyna Cay, Southwest Bank, Rifleman Bank, Swallow Reef

Territorial disputes

The sovereignty of many of the islands is disputed, as are economic claims.

Notes

Further reading

• C.S. Hutchison, V.R. Vijayan, "What are the Spratly Islands?" Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 39:371–385, 2010 PDF
• David Hancox, Victor Prescott, "A Geographical Description of the Spratly Islands and an Account of Hydrographic Surveys Amongst Those Islands", Maritime Briefing (University of Durham) 1:6, 1995, ISBN 1-897643-18-7 full text