Sledgehammer (Grey's Anatomy)

"Sledgehammer" is the season premiere of the twelfth season of the American television medical drama Grey's Anatomy, and the 246th episode overall. It aired on September 24, 2015 on ABC in the United States. The episode was written by Stacy McKee and directed by Kevin McKidd. On its initial airing the episode was watched by 9.55 million viewers and opened up to positive reviews from television critics. Earlier in April 2015, Patrick Dempsey had revealed that he would be leaving the show after the eleventh season despite having signed a contract through another season. Grey's Anatomy centers around a group of physicians struggling to balance their professional lives with their personal lives.

The episode focuses on the show's protagonist Dr. Meredith Grey's new living arrangement with her half-sister Dr. Maggie Pierce and her sister in law Dr. Amelia Shepherd in her old house after having lost her husband. Dr. Miranda Bailey fights to be the new Chief of Grey-Sloan Memorial with support from Dr. Richard Webber. Dr. Arizona Robbins and Dr. Callie Torres move on with their lives while the former looks for a new roommate. Dr. Alex Karev and Dr. Jo Wilson and Dr. Jackson Avery and Dr. April Kepner deal with their relationship problems with all the doctors trying to help two young girls who tried to commit suicide by jumping in front of a train after being bullied for being in love.

Plot

Three months after hosting Dr. Richard Webber (James Pickens Jr.) and Dr. Catherine Avery's (Debbie Allen) wedding, Meredith (Ellen Pompeo) finds herself moving back into her old house and adjusting to life with Amelia (Caterina Scorsone) and Maggie (Kelly McCreary). Meredith awakes to a banging sound. She races down the stairs to find Amelia putting a hole in the wall with a sledgehammer. Meredith asks what she's doing and Amelia says they talked about it. Meredith defends that they considered it and then they went to bed. Maggie straddles the line between supporting Amelia and supporting Meredith.

After being run over by a train, two fifteen-year old girls admit their love for each other, much to their parents dismay. Callie (Sara Ramirez) steps in to advocate for Jessica Tanner (Mandalynn Carlson), one of the girls, which outrages her mother, leading Maggie to punch her in the face. The fathers bond and learn to accept their daughters for who they are.

Maggie and Alex (Justin Chambers) also talk about being bullied with Callie and Jo (Camilla Luddington) respectively. Arizona (Jessica Capshaw) goes to pin a flyer looking for a roommate to the board, but after discovering from Stephanie (Jerrika Hinton) why no one will live with her, Arizona agrees to have an intern, Andrew (Giacomo Gianniotti), as her roommate.

Bailey (Chandra Wilson) is introduced to Dr. Tracy McConnell (Joey Lauren Adams), Catherine’s candidate for Chief of Surgery. Discouraged by how great Tracy is, Bailey withdraws from the race, but Ben (Jason George) manages to convince her to fight for the position, and Bailey is elected Chief of Surgery after giving her speech in mid-surgery. April (Sarah Drew) returns to Seattle after three months in Jordan only to find Jackson (Jesse Williams) less than warm and welcoming.

Meredith walks into the anatomy lab and tells them to forget everything they know about anatomy and start new with her. They all make the first incisions on their cadavers. Owen (Kevin McKidd) kisses Amelia. She asks what's happening, but Maggie comes out, pulls Amelia inside, and apologizes to Owen. Meredith makes up with Amelia, and tears down the wall and once the wall is broken through, they look through it and smile.

Production

The season was the first to air without Patrick Dempsey, following the death of his character in the previous season

The season premiere marked the first time in the course of the show when Dempsey was not included in the list of main cast members. On the absence of the male lead of the show creator Shonda Rhimes in an interview said, “It was so interesting for me to discover that audiences, especially women, are so conditioned to believe that there’s a singular fairy tale that nobody stops to think that that might not be the definition of happiness.” Rhimes continued, “Meredith knew that already. We got to the point in the season when Meredith said, “I can live without you, but I don’t want to,” which for any woman is a very powerful statement. It means: You compliment me, but you don’t complete me.” ABC also pictured Grey’s Anatomy without "McDreamy". The network’s president has said he hopes the show will continue for years after Patrick Dempsey’s alleged firing.

Pompeo in an interview with EW stated that the show would be just fine after Patrick and added that Meredith did not need a partner when other Shondaland characters — Scandal’s Olivia Pope (Kerry Washington) and How To Get Away With Murder’s Annalise Keating (Viola Davis) — lead shows on their own. She said, “Let’s keep it really real for a second and say this is really difficult for my ego” and added, “[...] somehow, Meredith Grey needs someone. Why can’t I just be the lead of the show the way Annalise and Olivia can? Why can’t I be on that poster by myself?”^[1][2]

It was revealed that Joey Lauren Adams will guest-star on the upcoming season of Grey’s Anatomy, ABC announced Friday. As revealed in the season 11 finale, Bailey (Chandra Wilson) will be competing to be the new Chief against a candidate that Catherine Avery (Debbie Allen) chooses as reported by Entertainment Weekly can reveal that the Chasing Amy and Switched at Birth star will play Bailey’s competition.^[3] Eric Lange , Maz Jobrani and Jenny Cooper co-star for the patient story involving two young girls who try to commit suicide.

Reception

Rating

"Sledgehammer" was originally broadcast on September 24, 2015 in the United States on the American Broadcasting Company (ABC). On its initial release the episode was watched by a total of 9.55 million viewers,^[4] a decline from the previous season premiere I Must Have Lost it on the Wind which was watched by 9.81 million viewers, but was a raise from the preceding episode the You're My Home which was watched by 8.33 million viewers. In the key 18-49 demographic, the episode scored a 2.8/10 in Nielsen ratings ranking at 22 in overall viewership rank and 14 in the 18-49 demographics. The premier episode was also ranked as the 4th most watched drama.^[5]

Reviews

"Sledgehammer" was received positive reviews from television critics with the majority of them praising the direction the show had brought back and noticing that the show was familiar with earlier seasons. Writer for TVFanatic Ashley Bissette Sumerel gave the episode a 4.5/5.0 score largely praising the episode and commented positive about the show returning to its roots. Sumerel praised the storyline about two girls falling inlove as she said "This is the sort of thing that makes Grey's Anatomy great. It doesn't hold back when it tackles subjects like bullying and homophobia."^[6]

Critics including Alex Hawkins of Western Gazette highlighted Ellen Pompeo's due for an Emmy Award.

Western Gazette also gave a positive review to the episode, "Within the first few minutes of the new episode, it’s clear that Grey’s Anatomy is returning to its roots. Overall, the first episode was a pleasant surprise and it was refreshing to see Rhimes head in a new direction. With Derek gone, Meredith can finally get the spotlight that she deserves without living in someone’s shadow and brings Grey’s back full circle to when we started the series." The site also gave Ellen Pompeo the credit for carrying the show saying." (It's) time for Pompeo to finally win an Emmy."^[7]

Entertainment Weekly praised the majority of the episode saying, "Take a deep breath. Just kidding, you don’t really need to, because that episode was fun." further noting the positives, " Good for Grey’s for tackling bullies, and good for them for doing it right in the beginning of the season. Sometimes cases of the week can be, well, weak, but this one was affecting and relevant. Plus, seeing Maggie get out her inner schoolyard bully was so, so satisfying, it’s good to hear more about Maggie’s life pre-Grey Sloan Memorial." for Ellen Pompeo's Meredith the site wrote, "The best line of the night goes to Meredith, who, during a conversation with Amelia about the whole wall thing, says, “That sounds like something tequila would say.” TV’s greatest relationship: Mer and tequila." and further went to add on Patrick Dempsey's absence, "This episode proved that, like Meredith said, we can live without him. Life continues on death, and so does television. So welcome back, Grey’s, and thanks for reminding us that life does indeed go on"^[8]

TVEquals praised the episode calling it a "tear-jerker" stated, "Overall, this was a great start to the twelfth season. I actually feel a bit on edge, as I wonder who among this group will have to endure heartache this season. I hope the writers will at least give Meredith and Amelia a well-earned break. I would be totally satisfied with watching Meredith, Amelia, Maggie and Callie drinking tequila and having a good time, but it wouldn’t be Grey’s Anatomy if that’s all that happened." "Heartbreaking. I love that Shondaland embraces diversity of all kinds and continues to tell stories involving LGBTQ characters."^[9]

Zap2it also praised the episode stating that the "two young girls in love have a powerful story".^[10] TVOM also praising Pompeo's character gave a positive review stating, "The show’s titular heroine had to learn to move forward with her life, and based on the season premiere, we would be wise to stick around for the journey. Yes we still mourn the loss of Dr. Derek Shepherd. Life moves on, and twelve seasons in, Shonda Rimes’s original sudsy drama has a strong, steady pulse."^[11]

Nad's Reviews gave a mixed to positive review to the episode review saying, "It was all fun, goofy material that managed to force a smile on my face and was entertaining all throughout. But boy was it old. Literally nothing feels fresh or original about this “new” Grey’s Anatomy. While the only medical case we had involved a touching, emotional story about two young girls in love, the whole episode just screamed predictable." The site too was positive about Pompeo saying, "And while I absolutely adore Ellen Pompeo, it’s hard to see this as Meredith’s show anymore. She gets adequate amount of screen-time and a few engaging moments, but she’s not driving this thing anymore. The whole cast is" The site also praised Debbie Allen and Chandra Wilson.^[12]

References