United States Senate election in New York, 1911

The 1911 United States Senate election in New York was held from January 17 to March 31, 1911, by the New York State Legislature to elect a U.S. Senator (Class 1) to represent the State of New York in the United States Senate.

Background

Republican Chauncey M. Depew had been re-elected to this seat in 1905, and his term would expire on March 3, 1911.

At the State election in November 1910, John Alden Dix was elected Governor, the first Democratic governor since 1894; 29 Democrats, 21 Republicans and 1 Independence Leaguer were elected for a two-year term (1911–1912) in the State Senate; and 86 Democrats, 63 Republicans and 1 Independence Leaguer^[1] were elected for the session of 1911 to the Assembly. The 134th New York State Legislature met from January 4 to October 6, 1911, at Albany, New York.

Candidates

First Democratic caucus

Ex-Lieutenant Governor William F. Sheehan announced his candidature formally in a letter to Mayor of Buffalo Louis P. Fuhrmann which was published on December 30, 1910. Before the State election, when a Democratic victory seemed to be improbable, Sheehan had made an agreement with Tammany Hall leader Charles Francis Murphy that the Tammany men would support Sheehan for the U.S. Senate.

The Democratic caucus met on January 16. 91 State legislators attended, but 25 were absent. Speaker Daniel D. Frisbie presided. The caucus nominated Sheehan. Edward M. Shepard, the defeated Democratic candidate for Mayor of New York in the election of 1901; and Ex-Supreme Court Justice D. Cady Herrick, the defeated Democratic candidate for Governor of New York in the election of 1904, also received votes at this caucus.

At the same time, an anti-Sheehan faction (in the press referred to as "the Insurgents") of 19 State legislators met at the Hampton Hotel, led by State Senator Franklin D. Roosevelt and issued a statement repudiating to take part in a caucus which follows orders from non-member political bosses.

Republican caucus

The Republican caucus met on January 16. They re-nominated the incumbent U.S. Senator Chauncey M. Depew unanimously.

Election proceedings

Deadlock

On January 17, both Houses of the State Legislature took ballots separately, but no choice was made in either. Sheehan received the votes of the 91 caucus attendees, only 1 short for a nomination in the State Senate, and 8 short in the Assembly. On January 18, the State Legislature met in joint session, compared the votes of the previous day, found that no choice was made, and proceeded to a joint ballot. On the joint ballot, Assemblyman Lewis S. Chanler, who had been Lieutenant Governor from 1907 to 1908, and the defeated Democratic candidate for the U.S. Senate in the election of 1909, deserted Sheehan, who received 90 votes, 9 short of election. As no choice was made, joint ballots continued to be taken every day, Monday through Saturday,^[2] at noon. Gov. Dix refused to interfere in the contest, but continued to talk privately to Mayor of New York William J. Gaynor, Boss Murphy and a few prospective compromise candidates.

On February 7, after the 18th ballot, the majority leaders, Robert F. Wagner of the State Senate and Al Smith of the Assembly, called a conference for the next morning at which both factions would discuss the further proceedings. Both factions met on February 8, maintained their positions, and nothing came of it. About this time, Edward M. Shepard was taken seriously ill, and he would die a few months later.

On February 20, after the 28th ballot, Congressman Martin W. Littleton announced formally his candidature for the senatorship. Littleton had received a few scattering votes throughout the balloting, but nothing came of it.

On February 23, after the 31st ballot, a letter was received from Congressman William Sulzer stating that, if a compromise candidate was sought, he would take the senatorship. Sulzer had received a few scattering votes since the 11th ballot, but nothing came of it either.

On February 25, after the 34th ballot, Edward M. Shepard withdrew from the contest and advised the election of a compromise candidate. Most of the Insurgents then voted for two ballots for John D. Kernan, and then for Littleton.

On February 28, after the 36th ballot, Sheehan sent an open letter to the State legislators in which he declared himself for a new caucus, and his acceptance of any candidate the caucus would choose. The Insurgents answered that a new caucus was useless.

On March 3, after the 39th ballot, Governor Dix advised to abandon Sheehan, and instead to elect immediately someone "whose choice will unite the Democratic Party." Sheehan however refused to withdraw from the contest unless a new caucus chose another candidate, and none of the legislators followed Dix's advice. On the same day, the term of the incumbent Chauncey M. Depew ended, and the seat became vacant on March 4.

President William H. Taft called a special session of the U.S. Senate to convene on April 4, and all parties expressed their hope that a U.S. Senator be elected by then.

On March 7, after the 42nd ballot, Mayor Gaynor seconded Gov. Dix, and advised to abandon Sheehan. Boss Murphy however re-affirmed his support for Sheehan, and the deadlock continued as before.

Intense negotiations followed to make the way clear for a new caucus. On March 18, Boss Murphy consented to a new caucus if the Insurgents accepted the candidate chosen, whoever it be. State Senator Roosevelt refused to be led into this trap, and on March 20 told Gov. Dix that the Insurgents would not be bound by the new caucus choice, expecting the Tammany majority to nominate somebody as objectionable as Sheehan, like Daniel F. Cohalan, De Lancey Nicoll or John B. Stanchfield. On March 22, after the 55th ballot, a conference of all Democratic legislators met and agreed unanimously to call a new caucus for March 27, to reconsider the nomination made on January 16.

Results, up to 58th ballot

Second Democratic caucus

In the morning of March 27, before the 59th ballot, State Senator Edgar T. Brackett, the Republican minority leader, tried to articulate a combination of Republicans and Insurgents to elect an independent Democrat, but was opposed by Edwin A. Merritt, the Republican minority leader in the Assembly, and the offer was turned down by State Senator Roosevelt.

The second Democratic caucus met on the evening of March 27, after the 59th ballot. President pro tempore of the State Senate Robert F. Wagner presided. 90 State legislators attended, among them only 4 Insurgents. Sheehan received 28 votes, and the remainder was scattered among 24 other men, but none for the Insurgents' frontrunner Martin W. Littleton. The caucus then adjourned to meet again on the next evening.

In the morning of March 28, before the 60th ballot, Chauncey M. Depew sent a telegram from Washington, D.C. releasing the Republican State legislators from their caucus pledges, and Merritt now voiced his support of the coalition scheme. Brackett announced that the Republicans would meet in a conference to consider the combination with the Insurgents.

The Democratic caucus met again in the evening of March 28, after the 60th ballot. Four ballots were taken, with no choice, and the caucus adjourned in the small hours of March 29 until the next morning. An hour after the adjournment, a fire broke out in the Assembly library which consumed the west wing of the New York State Capitol. The State Legislature moved to temporary accommodations in the Albany City Hall.

The Republican conference met in the morning of March 29, before the 61st ballot, but many legislators did not appear and no action was taken. Besides, taking the fire as an excuse, most Republicans paired with regular Democrats and went home, so that no quorum was present at the joint sessions of March 29 and 30.

The Democratic caucus met again on March 29, after the 61st ballot, but did not take any vote. State Senator Roosevelt led an Insurgent committee which informed the caucus attendees that, unless one of the names on a list submitted earlier (with the names of Herrick, Gerard, Straus, Glynn, Littleton, Dowling, Van Wyck, Parker, Kernan, Ridder and Carlisle) would be chosen, the Insurgents and Republicans would elect John D. Kernan on the next joint ballot of the State Legislature.

On March 30, the announced coalition did not materialize. Despite the Republican leaders supporting the scheme, most legislators did not attend the joint session. Besides, the Democratic caucus did not meet again, the negotiations continued only behind the scenes.

On March 31, Boss Murphy proposed James A. O'Gorman, a justice of the New York Supreme Court whose name had never been mentioned until the first meeting of the second caucus when O'Gorman received a single vote on the first ballot.^[16] After some debate, the Insurgents accepted O'Gorman. Thereupon the caucus met again, and 14 Insurgents attended, but Roosevelt did not. O'Gorman was nominated, and the State Legislature was convened in the evening to elect him. Thus ended the longest legislative deadlock in New York history after 74 days.

Election results, 59th through 64th ballot

Aftermath

By becoming a leader of the anti-Tammany legislators almost immediately after his election to the State Senate, and having survived ten weeks of what a biographer later described as "the full might of Tammany" against him, Roosevelt achieved his first victory as an elective official.^[23] This was the last U.S. senatorial election by the State Legislature. The U.S. Constitution was amended soon after, and since 1914 U.S. Senators have been elected statewide by popular ballot. O'Gorman took his seat on April 4, 1911, and served a single term, remaining in the U.S. Senate until March 3, 1917. In November 1916, Republican William M. Calder was elected to succeed O'Gorman.

Notes

1. ↑ The Independence League members usually caucused with the Democrats.
2. ↑ On Saturdays, and mostly on Mondays and Fridays, a large part of the State legislators preferred to be paired, and spent the week-end at home.
3. ↑ John Devereux Kernan (1844-1922), lawyer, son of Francis Kernan, State Railroad Commissioner 1882-87, Obit in NYT on December 30, 1922
4. ↑ Morgan Joseph O'Brien (1852-1937), NY Supreme Court justice 1887-1905, Obit in NYT on June 17, 1937 (subscription required)
5. ↑ Seymour Van Santvoord (1858-1938), lawyer, author, banker, of Troy, Counsel to Gov. John Alden Dix 1912, Chairman of the Public Service Commission 1914-18, Obit in NYT on November 16, 1938 (subscription required)
6. ↑ John C. R. Taylor (ca. 1866-1937), lawyer, of Middletown, state senator 1907-08, Obit in NYT on April 27, 1937 (subscription required)
7. ↑ John Hampden Dougherty (1849-1918), lawyer, of Brooklyn, father of Walter Hampden, author of The Electoral System of the United States
8. ↑ Herman N. Hansen (1870-1913), lawyer, of Brooklyn, Obit in NYT on December 1, 1913; [the Assembly journal states the name as "J. Hausen"]
9. ↑ John J. Hopper (d. 1923), civil engineer, of New York City, ran for Governor in 1910, State Chairman of the Independence League, Register of New York County 1915-18, Obit in NYT on May 17, 1923 (subscription required)
10. ↑ John Nelson Carlisle (1866-1931), lawyer, of Watertown
11. ↑ Edward Marshall Grout (1861-1931), of Brooklyn, Brooklyn Borough President 1898-1901, New York City Comptroller 1902-05, Obit in NYT on November 10, 1931 (subscription required)
12. ↑ Luke D. Stapleton (1869-1923), of Brooklyn, NY Supreme Court justice 1908-17, Obit in NYT on February 13, 1923 (subscription required)
13. ↑ Isaac Mark Kapper (b. 1864), of Brooklyn, New York University School of Law graduate 1887, NY Supreme Court justice 1911-34
14. ↑ Thomas Maurice Mulry (1855-1916), of New York City, President of the Emigrant Savings Bank, namesake of Mulry Square, Obit in NYT on March 12, 1916
15. ↑ Joseph Deyhoe Baucus, lawyer, of New York City, Princeton University graduate 1886
16. ↑ O'Gorman's nomination after three dozens of candidates were speculated about or voted for, while he was not even mentioned for 70 days, makes him possibly the "darkest horse" that ever won an election in the United States.
17. ↑ John Anderson Leach (1865-1936), lawyer, of Hollis, Queens, NYC Deputy Police Commissioner 1918-35
18. ↑ William Bruce Ellison (1857-1924), assemblyman 1893, NYC Water, Gas and Electricity Commissioner 1905-06, NYC Corporation Counsel 1906-07
19. ↑ James Armstrong Renwick (1857-1937), lawyer, of Flushing, Queens, President of the Village of Flushing before the Consolidation, ran for Queens Borough President in 1897 on the Citizens Union ticket, Obit in NYT on August 17, 1937 (subscription required)
20. ↑ Theodore Sutro (1845-1927), lawyer, of New York City, Harvard graduate 1871, Columbia Law School graduate 1874, NYC Tax Commissioner 1895-1901, Short bio and sketch in NYT on June 7, 1895; Obit in NYT on August 29, 1927 (subscription required)
21. ↑ John Lynn (d. 1933), merchant, of New York City, Obit in NYT on November 22, 1933 (subscription required)
22. ↑ Cosad was a sitting member of the State Assembly, and received a vote from Assemblyman John B. Trombly
23. ↑ Gunther, John (1950). Roosevelt in Retrospect. Harper & Brothers. pp. 203–204. 

Sources

• DEMOCRATS CONTROL LEGISLATURE BY 29 in NYT on November 10, 1910
• SHEEHAN IS LEADING IN SENATE CONTEST in NYT on December 31, 1910
• SHEEHAN NAMED; 25 BOLT CAUCUS; DEADLOCK NOW in NYT on January 17, 1911
• Journal of the Assembly (134th Session) (1911; Vol. I; states results of the vote in the Assembly on pg. 56f, and of the joint ballots through March 28)
• BLOCK SHEEHAN; ...Twenty-one Democrats Pledged Against Him in NYT on January 18, 1911
• REPUBLICAN PLOT TO ELECT SHEEHAN in NYT on January 19, 1911
• THE INSURGENT ROLL OF HONOR in NYT on January 19, 1911 [This article gives a remarkably early insight into the reasons behind the "Insurgency"; i.e. Franklin D. Roosevelt was determined to follow step by step the career of his relative Theodore Roosevelt. Theodore started his political career as a first-term assemblyman upsetting the party machine, and Franklin did exactly that now. Later, Franklin would be, like Theodore, Asst. Secr. of the Navy, Gov. of New York, and vice presidential candidate, until finally achieving the presidency, his goal which he had set himself in 1910.]
• SHEEHAN LOSES TWO MORE VOTES in NYT on January 20, 1911
• LOOMIS NOW READY TO DESERT SHEEHAN in NYT on January 21, 1911
• SHEEHAN'S FORCES DWINDLING AWAY in NYT on January 22, 1911
• 86 SHEEHAN VOTES ON FIFTH BALLOT in NYT on January 24, 1911
• DIX MAY YET END SENATORSHIP FIGHT in NYT on January 25, 1911
• REVOLT IN CAMP OF MURPHY MEN in NYT on January 26, 1911
• EXPECT DARK HORSE TO WIN SENATORSHIP in NYT on January 27, 1911
• LOOK FOR SHEEHAN TO WITHDRAW SOON in NYT on January 28, 1911
• SHEEHAN RELUCTANT TO QUIT SENATE RACE in NYT on January 29, 1911
• MURPHY CONFERS WITH ROOSEVELT in NYT on January 31, 1911
• NO COMPROMISE YET IN SENATE CONTEST in NYT on February 1, 1911
• MURPHY NOT READY TO DESERT SHEEHAN in NYT on February 2, 1911
• SEE AN END SOON TO SENATE FIGHT in NYT on February 3, 1911
• GLYNN OR LITTLETON MAY END DEADLOCK in NYT on February 4, 1911
• TELLS OF MURPHY CONFERENCE in NYT on February 5, 1911
• SHEEHAN AGAIN FAILS TO WIN DIX'S AID.; ...SHEPARD SAID TO BE ILL in NYT on February 7, 1911
• SEE AN END TO-DAY IN SENATOR FIGHT in NYT on February 8, 1911
• CONFERENCE FAILS TO BREAK DEADLOCK in NYT on February 9, 1911
• DIX WILL CONSULT GAYNOR TO-MORROW in NYT on February 10, 1911
• DEADLOCKED FOUR WEEKS in NYT on February 11, 1911
• IGNORE SHEEHAN MEETING in NYT on February 12, 1911
• ONLY 21 VOTES FOR SENATOR in NYT on February 14, 1911
• TWENTY-FOURTH ALBANY VOTE in NYT on February 15, 1911
• NO SHEEHAN GAINS AFTER HIS MEETING in NYT on February 16, 1911
• ANOTHER WEEK'S DEADLOCK in NYT on February 17, 1911
• MURPHY MAY YET FORCE SHEEHAN OUT in NYT on February 18, 1911
• (No title) in NYT on February 19, 1911
• LITTLETON ENTERS SENATORIAL RACE in NYT on February 20, 1911
• ASK INVESTIGATION OF SHEEHAN TACTICS in NYT on February 21, 1911
• ASK DIX TO END DEADLOCK in NYT on February 22, 1911
• SHEPARD WON'T QUIT TILL SHEEHAN DOES in NYT on February 24, 1911
• SHEEHAN HOLDS ON IN FACE OF REVOLT in NYT on February 25, 1911
• TO STUMP THE STATE AGAINST SHEEHAN in NYT on February 26, 1911
• MR. SHEPARD'S LETTER.; Withdraws... in NYT on February 27, 1911
• PRESSING SHEEHAN TO QUIT in NYT on February 28, 1911
• SHEEHAN IS FOR A NEW CAUCUS in NYT on March 1, 1911
• SAY NEW CAUCUS IS USELESS in NYT on March 1, 1911
• DIX, WORRIED, HOPES FOR ANOTHER CAUCUS in NYT on March 2, 1911
• DIX AND GAYNOR MAY FORCE MURPHY TO ACT in NYT on March 3, 1911
• DIX NOW SAYS DROP SHEEHAN in NYT on March 4, 1911
• MURPHY STILL HOLDS KEY in NYT on March 5, 1911
• SHEEHAN TELLS DIX HE WON'T WITHDRAW in NYT on March 6, 1911
• ANTI-SHEEHAN BREAK SOON in NYT on March 7, 1911
• TURN AGAINST DIX AS DEADLOGK HOLDS in NYT on March 8, 1911
• GAYNOR UPHOLDS DIX IN FIGHT ON SHEEHAN in NYT on March 9, 1911
• SHEEHAN BOOM NEAR AN UTTER COLLAPSE in NYT on March 10, 1911
• LULL IN SENATORIAL FIGHT in NYT on March 11, 1911
• EXPECT ANOTHER DIX LETTER in NYT on March 12, 1911
• DIX HOPEFUL AFTER TALK WITH MURPHY in NYT on March 15, 1911
• DIX WAITS TO HEAR WHAT MURPHY SAYS in NYT on March 16, 1911
• DECLARES STETSON BACKS INSURGENTS in NYT on March 17, 1911
• JEST AS THEY VOTE IN VAIN FOR SENATOR in NYT on March 18, 1911
• ALBANY LIKES FRISBIE'S STAND in NYT on March 19, 1911
• MURPHY HALTS PLAN TO BREAK DEADLOCK in NYT on March 21, 1911
• NEW CALL GOES OUT TO END SENATE FIGHT in NYT on March 22, 1911
• CAUCUS NEXT MONDAY in NYT on March 23, 1911
• SHEEHAN FIGHTS ON DESPITE NEW CAUCUS in NYT on March 24, 1911
• ALBANY EXPECTS AGREEMENT in NYT on March 25, 1911
• SUDDEN CALL TO LEGISLATORS in NYT on March 26, 1911
• WON'T WITHDRAW, DECLARES SHEEHAN in NYT on February 27, 1911
• SHEEHAN LOSES IN NEW CAUCUS in NYT on March 28, 1911
• Journal of the Assembly (134th Session) (1911; Vol. II; states results of joint ballots of March 29 to 31)
• CAUCUS AGAIN BALLOTS IN VAIN in NYT on March 29, 1911
• $5,000,000 LOSS IN CAPITOL FIRE; West Wing Wrecked and State Library, with Historic Records, Almost Destroyed in NYT on March 30, 1911
• LIKELY TO ELECT SENATOR TO-DAY in NYT on March 30, 1911
• HITCH IN THE PLANS TO NAME A SENATOR in NYT on March 31, 1911
• NAME O'GORMAN FOR SENATOR in NYT on April 1, 1911